Yesterday morning I got up at the butt crack of dawn -- on my day off -- to fulfill a few mandatory clinical hours. As part of my 5 credit community nursing rotation, I was scheduled to spend the day with parish nurses at a food bank in a very rural, destitute community (which is more than an hour's drive from my house). The parish nurses also happened to be nuns. Sisters of Charity, no less. I am not Catholic; I don't think I'd ever even spoken to a nun before yesterday. I wasn't sure what to expect... 
We showed up at the food bank, my friend Dave and I, at 8:00 in the morning. Two nuns were already there; they were friendly and hospitable people, which didn't surprise me. They were making coffee and tea and they graciously offered us some. One of them took a pizza out of the freezer, added extra cheese to it, and cooked it for breakfast... which did surprise me. I had an ignorant mental image of nuns drinking water and eating bread without butter. They didn't wear black habits, either; they wore plain, matronly skirts and granny shoes and had short hair. I'd expected the whole "holier than thou" thing, I suppose.
Before the nuns had finished their morning pizza, the food truck arrived. We unloaded it; my arms are sore today from carrying sacks of potatoes, cases of soup, boxes of cereal, and miscellaneous foodstuffs from the truck into the food bank. That process alone took a few hours.
Soon after, folks began to creep in to collect. They had laundry baskets and huge boxes with them to make their food collection process easier. I saw elderly couples, single mothers with small children, old men, young women.
As usual, I made a few subjective observations concerning charity itself...
Some people truly need it. And deserve it, as well. The elderly couples who have to choose whether they buy their medications or eat. The single mother who's juggling two jobs, both of which pay minimum wage, plus raise her kids and keep their bellies full. Some situations call for charity.
Some don't.
Since Dave was the only guy there, he was elected by the nuns to be the official box and bag carrier. For hours, he carried boxes of food to the backseats of these folks' cars. Some of these vehicles were nicer than the ones that he and I drive. When he would open the back door to put the box of charitable food items in, he more than once sat them next to a case of beer or a carton of cigarettes. I was inside handing out loaves of bread and sacks of potatoes. One woman asked me if I had any rye, and when I said I didn't, she complained and requested that next time, damn it, she'd rather have some rye. "Have" is the operational word there. I assumed that beggars can't be choosers, but I suppose I was as wrong about that as I was about the nuns and their butterless bread.
Another woman stumbled into the food bank dead drunk; she could barely walk, much less carry a heavy box. The sisters filled her box for her, and Dave carried it to her car -- and then she drove away.
It is blatantly obvious to me that charity, the epitome of humanitarianism, is far too often abused and used by those who actually believe that this big, bad world owes them something. Give a man a fish; feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish; feed him for a lifetime. I think Tzo had something there. Giving is fine, and in some cases, perfectly feasible. But how much is expected of us? How much are we expected to give? How far does charity go before it begins to become a crutch? And worse, downright expected by those who receive it? The woman that wanted rye... She has obviously become so desensitized to charity that she now believes it is her right. Not only to be given free bread, but rye bread, damn it. You nuns get your act together and get the right kind of bread up in here, for the love of God.
I have to hand it to those sisters -- they are true humanitarians. They prayed for compassion and nothing else. They prayed to be able to serve others graciously. They ask nothing for themselves. I saw them hug people that I would have taken a bar of soap and a garden hose to first. They deserve that morning pizza with extra cheese.I pray for compassion, too. I also pray that the rye lady endeavors to deserve the bread that she so shamelessly complained about.
I won't hold my breath.